top of page

Indirect Analysis: Lacan, Kierkegaard And Humour

The Letter, Issue 30, Spring 2004, Pages 101 - 110


INDIRECT ANALYSIS: LACAN, KIERKEGAARD AND HUMOUR*

Marcus Pound


In Seminar II Lacan identifies Kierkegaard as a 'humorist'.[1] Why did Lacan describe Kierkegaard as a humorist and not as a Christian or a melancholic? Humour played a crucial role in Kierkegaard's critique of Hegel: rather than simply express outrage at Hegel's project, Kierkegaard used humour to indirectly challenge him. In this paper I suggest that Kierkegaard's indirect critique illuminates a role for humour in Lacanian analysis; and in turn, Lacanian analysis illuminates a role for humour in theology. This paper consists of four parts. First, I consider Freud and Lacan's views of humour. Second, I look at Kierkegaard's view of humour. Third, I compare the two in the light of analysis. Fourth, I reflect on analysis, humour, and theology.

Freud and Lacan's views of humour

Lacan often makes the association between analysis and humour. For example Lacan says:

The closer we get to psychoanalysis being funny the more it is real psychoanalysis. Later on, it will get run in, it will be done by cutting corners and by pulling tricks. No one will understand any longer what's being done, just as there is no longer any need to understand anything about optics to make a microscope.[2]

Moreover, in his seminar on sexuality Lacan delights in Freud's name, Freude being the German for joy or pleasure: 'Freud, what a funny name - Kraft durch Freud [strength through Freud/strength through joy], it's a whole platform! It is the funniest leap in the sacred farce of history'.[3]


Want to read more?

Subscribe to theletter.ie to keep reading this exclusive post.

Related Posts

See All

Desire Unto Death: Childsplay

Earlier on the week I noticed that in the course of Seminar II Lacan says the following: You can disprove Hegel but not the Song of...

Klein's Bottle: Getting Real

When Freud himself admitted that he had underestimated the negative - 'I can no longer understand how we have overlooked the ubiquity of...

Issue 30: Editorial

Ten years ago, the first issue of THE LETTER was published. As you begin to read this, the thirtieth issue of the journal, perhaps you...

Comments

Couldn’t Load Comments
It looks like there was a technical problem. Try reconnecting or refreshing the page.
bottom of page